Traditional culture in a polycentric world. Article 2. Traditional culture in the context of the challenges of modernization. Russian experience in a comparative-historical perspective
Table of contents
Share
Metrics
Traditional culture in a polycentric world. Article 2. Traditional culture in the context of the challenges of modernization. Russian experience in a comparative-historical perspective
Annotation
PII
S086904990002760-8-1
DOI
10.31857/S086904990002760-8
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Olga Shemyakina 
Occupation: Chief Researcher, Department of Russian History until the beginning of the XIX century, Faculty of History, Moscow State University
Affiliation: Faculty of History, Lomonosov Moscow State University
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Edition
Pages
174-186
Abstract

The achievement of an optimal balance of the values of modernization (a single complex of which was first formed in the West in the 17th-18th centuries) and traditional culture, including its archaic component, is a necessary condition for achieving the integrity of national organisms. Ignoring the creative potential of traditional culture, including archaism, the inability to enter into a constructive dialogue with it is one of the main factors that gave rise to the crisis of both the Western civilization discourse and the first Russian “modern” project – “St. Petersburg Russia” since the XVIII century. The fact that such a constructive dialogue was in principle quite possible is convincingly demonstrated by the author's conclusion about the example of the Russian Old Believers, the key role that they played in the process of capitalist modernization of Russia in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the own project of Russia's renewal of P. Ryabushinsky and his adherents assuming an organic mix of the heritage of pre-Petrine Russia and the values of modernization.

Keywords
modernization, traditinal society, modern-project, Aristotelian paradigm, archaic
Received
28.12.2018
Date of publication
28.12.2018
Number of purchasers
1
Views
167
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should sign in

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue
0 RUB / 0.0 SU
All issues for 2018
2112 RUB / 30.0 SU
1

References

1. Akhiezer A.S. (2006) Trudy [Works]. Moscow: New Chronograph.

2. Etkind A., Uffelman D., Kukulin I. (2012) Vnutrennyaya kolonizatsiya Rossii: mezhdu praktikoy i voobrazheniyem [Internal colonization of Russia: between practice and imagination]. Tam, vnutri. Praktiki vnutrenney kolonizatsii v kul'turnoy istorii. Moscow: New literary review, pp. 31–56.

3. Ilyin V.N. (1997) Esse o russkoy kul'ture [An essay on Russian culture]. St.-Petersburg: Acropolis.

4. Kartashev A.V. (1992) Smysl staroobryadchestva [The meaning of the Old Belief ]. Church. The Old Believers' Church and Public Journal, no. 2, pp. 18–20.

5. Kerov V.V. (2005b) Novyy stroy lichnosti i novyy tip religioznosti v staroobryadchestve [A new personality structure and a new type of religiosity in the Old Believers ]. Lipovane. History and culture of the Russian Old Believers. Issue 2. Odessa: ONU, pp. 3–9.

6. Kerov V.V. (2005а) “Se chelovek i delo yego…”: Konfessional'no-eticheskiye faktory staroobryadcheskogo predprinimatel'stva v Rossii ["This man and his work...": Confessional-ethical factors of Old Believer business in Russia]. Мoscow: EKON-INFORM.

7. Koposov N.E. (2001) Kak dumayut istoriki [As historians think]. Moscow: New literary review.

8. Malyavin V.V. (2011) Sredotochiya: Izbrannyye esse, doklady, interv'yu, retsenzii [Focus: Selected essays, reports, interviews, reviews]. Ivanovo: Roshcha Akademii.

9. Medushevsky A.N. (2014) Rossiyskaya pravovaya traditsiya: opora ili pregrada? [Russian legal tradition: a pillar or a barrier?]. Moscow: The Liberal Mission.

10. Mel'nikov F.Ye. (1911) Bluzhdayushcheye bogosloviye [Wandering theology]. Moscow: Tipografiya P.P. Ryabushinskogo.

11. Milkov V.V. (1997) Predisloviye [Foreword], Drevnyaya Rus': peresecheniye traditsiy [Ancient Rus’: The crossroads of traditions]. Moscow: Scientific and Publishing Center “Skrintory”, pp. 3–10.

12. Panchenko A.M. (1984) Russkaya kul'tura v kontse petrovskikh reform [Russian culture at the end of Peter's reforms]. Leningrad: Nauka.

13. Pigin A.V. (2006) Videniya potustoronnego mira v russkoy rukopisnoy knizhnosti [Visions of the Otherworld in Russian Manuscript Book]. St.-Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin.

14. Ryabushinsky V.P. (1994) Staroobryadchestvo i russkoye religioznoye chuvstvo [Old Believers and Russian religious feeling]. Moscow; Jerusalem: Bridges.

15. Scheffel D. (1992) Staraya vera i russkiy tserkovnyy obryad [Old Faith and Russian Church Rite]. Traditsionnaya dukhovnaya i material'naya kul'tura russkikh staroobryadcheskikh poseleniy v stranakh Evropy, Azii i Ameriki [The traditional spiritual and material culture of Old-Believers’ settlements at the European, Asian and American countries]. Novosibirsk: Nauka, pp. 22–27.

16. Shakhov M.O. (1998) Filosofskiye aspekty staroveriya [Philosophical aspects of the Old Belief]. Moscow: Publishing House “Third Rome”.

17. Shemyakin Ya.G. (2001) Evropa i Latinskaya Amerika: vzaimodeystviye tsivilizatsiy v kontekste vsemirnoy istorii [Europe and Latin America: the interaction of civilizations in the context of world history]. Moscow: Science.

18. Shemyakina O.D. (1994) Emotsional'nie pregrady vo vzaimoponimanii kul'turnykh obshchnostey (zametki istorika o mezhgruppovoy vrazhdebnosti) [Emotional barriers in mutual understanding of cultural communities (historian's notes on intergroup hostility)]. Obshchestvennie nauki i sovremennost’, no. 4, pp. 104–114.

19. Shemyakina O.D. (2008) Vlast' linii v rossiyevedenii i nelineynyy kharakter rossiyskogo khaokosmosa [The Power of the Line in Russian Studies and the Nonlinear Character of Russian Chaos Cosmos]. Obshchestvennie nauki i sovremennost’, no. 2, pp. 92–103.

20. Shemyakin Ya.G., Shemyakina O.D. (2006) Staroobryadchestvo i protsess formoobrazovaniya v rossiyskoy tsivilizatsii [Old Believers and the Process of Formation in Russian Civilization]. Obshchestvennie nauki i sovremennost’, no. 2, pp. 98–108.

21. Sledzevsky I.V. (2005) Modeli khaosa v global'nom i tsivilizatsionnom videnii [Models of Chaos in a Global and Civilizational Vision]. Granitsy. Rubezh. Perekhod. Sotsiokul'turnoye pogranich'ye v global'nom i regional'nom aspektakh [Customs. Border. Transfer. Social-cultural borders at the global and regional aspects]. Moscow: RAS Institute of African Studies, pp. 89–99.

22. Smilyanskaya E.B. (2003) Volshebniki. Bogokhul'niki. Yeretiki. Narodnaya religioznost' i “dukhovnie prestupleniya” v Rossii XVIII v. [The Wizards. Blasphemers. Heretics. Folk religiosity and “spiritual crimes” in Russia in the XVIII century]. Moscow: Indrik.

23. Toporov V.N. (1995) Svyatost' i svyatie v russkoy dukhovnoy kul'ture. T.1. Perviy vek khristianstva na Rusi [Holiness and Saints in Russian Spiritual Culture. Vol.1. The first century of Christianity in Russia]. Moscow: “Gnosis” – School “Languages of Russian culture”.

24. Weber M. (1990) Izbrannyye proizvedeniya [Selected works]. Moscow: Progress.

25. Wolff L. (2003) Izobretaya Vostochnuyu Evropu: Karta tsivilizatsii v soznanii epokhi Prosveshcheniya [Inventing Eastern Europe: The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment]. Moscow: New literary review.

26. Yakimovich A. (1995) Magicheskaya vselennaya. Ocherki po iskusstvu, filosofii i literatury XX veka [The Magical Universe. Essays on art, philosophy and literature of the XX century]. Moscow: Galart.

27. Zhivov V.M. (2002) Razyskaniya v oblasti istorii i predystorii russkoy kul'tury [Research in the field of history and prehistory of Russian culture]. Moscow: Languages of Slavic culture.